| | |

Easy Ice Cream Sandwiches

Please note that this post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Rewards Style influencer and Jane Influencer, we earn from qualifying purchases and any sales made through such links will reward us a small commission – at no extra cost for you.

Easy Ice Cream Sandwiches

Friends, you are in for a definite treat today – like, literally. We are sharing our take on easy ice cream sandwiches, just in time for Valentine’s Day dessert.

Welcome to this month’s installment of  Thrifty Style Team! Typically, this is the place where we get together with our talented and creative blogger friends every month. We each makeover, repurpose or transform something from our homes or thrift stores.  This month however, we have changed things up a bit. Being that this is the season of love, we decided to each share a dessert recipe. Let’s get started!

Staying Home

In our lives, we typically don’t do a lot for Valentine’s Day. We each prefer to stay home and celebrate by making a special meal and dessert. Being that we aren’t comfortable with going inside of a restaurant just yet,  we knew that we needed to make the day of love a bit more festive. 

When Jenn was a little girl, we would make ice cream sandwiches with fresh baked cookies. Usually, it was peanut butter cookies filled with vanilla ice cream. We decided the cookies needed to be a bit over-the-top for our special dessert.

Make it Easy

What’s easier than starting this dessert treat, than with store bought cookies. You deserve to take it easy too. Our Valentine cookies came with a kit and edible markers. We opted to skip this and just add red icing to the tops. We love the pop of red. You can even use smaller cookies for this recipe.

Easy Ice Cream Sandwiches

Prep Time 5 minutes
Total Time 5 minutes


  • Store bought, heart shaped cookies
  • Pint of your favorite ice cream.We used a pint of Häagen Dazs, strawberry.
  • Sprinkles


  1. Use 2 cookies for each ice cream sandwich
  2. Lay the pint of ice cream on its side. Using a sharp knife, cut through the carton and the ice cream.
  3. Again, using a sharp knife cut out a V shape from the top of your ice cream circle. (see photo).
  4. Lay ice cream on the backside of one cookie.
  5. Dip the ice cream onto a plate of sprinkles.
  6. Top the ice cream with another cookie.
  7. Place on a tray in the freezer until you are ready for dessert.
We love Häagen Dazs strawberry ice cream. Plus, the pink color is perfect for our sandwiches. Feel free to use your favorite pint of ice cream.

Colorful sprinkles are so festive!

Turn it

Turn the pint of ice cream on its side. Carefully use a sharp knife and cut slices of ice cream, through the ice cream container.
Next, cut a V from the ice cream slice.
Place the ice cream slice on a cookie.
Por sprinkles onto a plate.
Carefully turn the cookie over and dip the ice cream on the sprinkles.
Place another on top of the ice cream to create your sandwich.
Place in the freezer until you’re ready to serve!
These easy ice cream sandwiches are so much fun to make. They aren’t just for Valentine’s Day either. You can use any type of hard cookie and ice cream combination!

Don’t forget to Pin this to your favorite Pinterest Board!

We hope you give our recipe a try! Now let’s see what our Thrifty Style Team members have cooked up!


  1. These are adorable! And they’re perfect for a sweet Valentine’s day treat! Love the sprinkles and the fact that you made it super simple by using store-bought cookies! Thanks for the recipe.

  2. Rebecca Payne says:

    Looks so good. YUM!

  3. You girls are just as smart as can be! I love these and I know my grands will too. I am a HUGE Haagen Daz fan, (Did I ever tell you that I managed one of there shops?) so this is perfect for me. Especially with the store bought cookies. Thanks for sharing, my friends!

  4. These look amazing! I would have a very hard time resisting these LOL! Thanks for sharing your shortcuts, slicing the ice cream container is brilliant! Pinned 😉

  5. Yes please! I can’t wait to try these with my girls. So smart to cut the ice cream…I love that part! Adorable and pinning!

  6. These are the cutest! Love the sprinkles and the awesome trick to cut the pint of ice cream!!!

  7. Oh my goodness! These not only sounds amazing but the pictures are gorgeous! You had me at Haagen Dazs! Thank you for sharing this yummy dessert. 😀

  8. Ladies, these look so pretty and delicious and my favorite part…they’re simple to make! Thank you for sharing this wonderful idea.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.